Community listing

Buy Gold and Silver Coins

18 reviews .
★★★☆☆
3.1
Money & Insurance
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Money & Insurance https://www.amergold.com/

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Brian Whitmore
Nashville, Tennessee, USA
★★☆☆☆

Really disappointing experience. I placed an order for two gold American Eagles and was told shipping would take 5 to 7 business days. Two weeks later, nothing. When I finally got someone on the phone after multiple attempts, I was told there was a 'processing delay' with no further explanation. The coins did eventually arrive but one of them had visible scratches that weren't mentioned in the listing. Getting a resolution on that was like pulling teeth. Won't be ordering from them again.

Gold Dealer May 17, 2025
Connie Ashford
Little Rock, Arkansas, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Absolutely terrible customer service. I sold a small collection of silver coins to this company and was quoted a price over the phone. When the check arrived it was nearly 15 percent less than what I was quoted with no explanation letter or breakdown included. When I called to dispute it, the representative was dismissive and rude and basically told me I misremembered the quote. I had written it down during the call. This felt dishonest and I would caution anyone thinking about selling their coins here.

Gold and Silver Trading Company Apr 3, 2025
Douglas Pennington
Spokane, Washington, USA
★★☆☆☆

I reached out to their financial consulting service hoping to get some guidance on how to allocate a portion of my savings into precious metals. The person I spoke with seemed more interested in pushing specific high-premium products than actually listening to my goals. I asked about lower-premium bullion options and kept getting steered back toward numismatic coins with much higher markups. Felt more like a sales pitch than genuine financial advice. I ended up going with a different company.

Financial Consultant Jan 27, 2025
Tamara Breckenridge
Des Moines, Iowa, USA
★☆☆☆☆

My order took over three weeks to arrive with virtually no communication from the company during that time. I sent three emails and only got one response that said my order was 'in process.' When the silver bars finally showed up, the packaging was damaged and one bar had a deep gouge on it. The return process has been an absolute nightmare — I've been going back and forth for six weeks now and still haven't received a replacement or refund. This is unacceptable for a company dealing in high-value goods.

Gold and Silver Trading Company Nov 16, 2024
Victor Sandoval
El Paso, Texas, USA
★★★☆☆

Mixed experience. The coins I received were fine and priced reasonably but the whole process felt unnecessarily complicated. The website had conflicting information about payment methods and when I tried to use a wire transfer I was given different instructions by two different people. Eventually got it sorted out but it shouldn't have taken four phone calls. For the amount of money involved in these transactions I expect a more professional and consistent process. Might give them another try but not soon.

Coin Dealer Nov 9, 2024
Janet Moorefield
Richmond, Virginia, USA
★☆☆☆☆

I ordered three Morgan silver dollars described as Very Fine condition. What arrived looked closer to Fine or even Very Good at best. When I sent photos to customer service pointing out the discrepancy in the grading they basically told me grading is subjective and refused to offer a return. Grading standards are not that subjective when the difference is this obvious. I've been collecting for 15 years and I know what a VF coin looks like. Felt like I was deliberately misled. Avoid.

Coin Dealer Sep 18, 2024
Howard Blankenship
Omaha, Nebraska, USA
★★☆☆☆

The website shows prices that look competitive but there are additional fees that only show up at checkout — handling fees, insurance fees, and a 'processing charge' that together added almost 8 percent to my total. I understand some fees are standard in this industry but they should be disclosed upfront, not buried at the end of the checkout process. I felt a bit tricked. The coins themselves were fine but the pricing transparency is a serious issue.

Gold Dealer Jun 18, 2024
Melissa Forthright
Hartford, Connecticut, USA
★★★☆☆

I used their financial consulting service before making my first gold purchase. The advice wasn't bad exactly but it was very generic — the kind of information I could have found on any precious metals website. I was hoping for personalized guidance based on my specific financial situation but the consultant didn't ask many questions before launching into a standard pitch. For the consultation fee they charge I expected more. I did ultimately buy some gold coins from them and those were fine.

Financial Consultant May 26, 2024