Community listing

The Fossil Exchange

16 reviews .
★★★☆☆
3.3
Hobbies & Crafts
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Raymond Stokes
Albuquerque, NM, USA
★★☆☆☆

Disappointed with my recent purchase. I ordered what was listed as a Grade A trilobite and what arrived looked more like a heavily restored piece with visible filler and paint that wasn't disclosed in the description. When I emailed about it I got a vague response saying that some restoration is standard in the industry, which I understand, but not when it's not disclosed upfront. I had to push through two more emails to get a partial refund. Not a smooth experience.

Fossil Purchase - Trilobite Specimen Oct 25, 2025
Brenda Tolliver
Cleveland, OH, USA
★☆☆☆☆

My order arrived shattered. The ammonite I ordered was clearly just loosely wrapped in a single layer of tissue paper inside a thin cardboard box with no padding on the sides or bottom. Half of it broke off and there were cracks all over the main piece. I sent photos immediately and it took over two weeks to get any response. They eventually offered store credit but I don't want store credit, I wanted the item I paid for. This whole experience was frustrating and unprofessional.

Fossil Purchase - Ammonite Aug 21, 2025
Kevin Hargrove
Memphis, TN, USA
★★☆☆☆

I ordered a megalodon tooth that was listed as five to six inches. What showed up was barely four inches. I measured it three times. When I contacted customer service they told me measurements are approximate and refer to the longest edge, which was not explained anywhere in the listing. The tooth itself is nice but I feel misled by the description. For the price I paid, accuracy in listing details really matters.

Fossil Purchase - Megalodon Tooth Aug 8, 2025
Tamara Elkins
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
★★★☆☆

Mixed experience overall. The fossil itself, a small raptor claw, was nice enough and looked authentic. But the shipping took nearly three weeks with no tracking updates after the first day, and I had to email twice to get any update at all. When the package finally arrived, the display stand listed in the product description was missing. They did ship it separately after I pointed it out, but it felt like I had to manage too much of this myself. Just needs better logistics and communication.

Fossil Purchase - Raptor Claw Jul 10, 2025
Gerald Fontaine
Baton Rouge, LA, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Spent over $300 on a dinosaur bone fragment that arrived with zero documentation, no certificate, no provenance info, nothing. The listing clearly stated that documentation was included. I've now sent four emails over six weeks and haven't gotten a satisfactory answer. One rep told me the documentation must have fallen out during packing and then went silent. I'm considering disputing the charge with my credit card company at this point. Extremely poor customer service.

Fossil Purchase - Dinosaur Bone Fragment May 12, 2025
Nicole Ashworth
Indianapolis, IN, USA
★★☆☆☆

The website photos are heavily edited and don't represent the actual color or condition of the specimens accurately. The shark tooth I ordered looked jet black and glossy in the listing but arrived as a dull grayish-brown with visible chips on the edges. I understand natural variation but the difference was significant enough that I felt the listing was misleading. Returns are also complicated and not clearly explained on the site. Took a lot of back and forth to sort out.

Fossil Purchase - Shark Tooth Apr 7, 2025
Patrick Drummond
Omaha, NE, USA
★☆☆☆☆

I ordered a gift in early November for a Christmas present and it still hasn't arrived as of mid-December. Tracking shows the package has been sitting at a regional hub for almost three weeks. Customer service blamed the carrier but made no effort to investigate, reship, or offer any solution. I had to find a last-minute replacement gift. Still waiting on a refund. For the prices they charge I expected far better handling and accountability.

Fossil Purchase - Gift Order Mar 6, 2025
Cheryl Maddox
Spokane, WA, USA
★★★☆☆

The fossil crab I ordered was genuinely cool but the experience getting it was stressful. The site had it listed as in stock but after I placed my order I got an email three days later saying it was backordered. No estimated timeline was given. After waiting two weeks I finally got it and it was nice, but the lack of proactive communication during the delay was frustrating. If they were upfront about stock issues I'd probably be giving this four stars.

Fossil Purchase - Fossil Crab Jan 18, 2025