I had a frustrating experience with Rare Carat that I feel I need to share. The diamond I received looked noticeably different from the online photos. The color appeared at least two grades warmer than advertised and when I reached out to customer service it took over a week to get a response. When I asked about returning the stone the process was complicated and required me to ship it back at my own expense before any refund would be considered. For a premium purchase I expected much better service.
Business Overview
Core company details visible to potential customers.
Customer Reviews
Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.
I expected more from a company with so many glowing reviews. The diamond I purchased was listed as VS2 clarity but when I had it independently appraised locally the appraiser pointed out inclusions that he would have graded SI1. When I brought this up with Rare Carat they kept pointing me to the GIA certificate and were not willing to engage with my concerns meaningfully. The customer service rep I spoke with was dismissive. I won't be shopping here again.
I wanted to love Rare Carat because the concept is great, but my experience was disappointing. I ordered a wholesale lot of smaller diamonds for a jewelry project and several stones arrived with chips that were not disclosed in the listing. Getting through to someone who could actually help was a challenge. After multiple emails and a phone call I was offered a store credit rather than a refund. I needed the money back, not a credit, and the unwillingness to accommodate that felt really unreasonable.