Community listing

Rare Carat

21 reviews .
★★★★☆
3.8
Shopping & Fashion
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Shopping & Fashion https://www.rarecarat.com/

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Jordan Whitfield
Denver, CO, USA
★★★★☆

Really impressed with the transparency Rare Carat offers. I compared probably 50 diamonds before settling on a cushion cut for my wife's anniversary gift. The filters let me dial in exactly what I wanted by carat, cut, color, and price. Shipping was fast and the stone arrived securely packaged with all the certification documents. The only reason I'm not giving five stars is that the website can get a little slow when loading comparison pages, but overall a fantastic buying experience.

Diamond Dealer Jan 24, 2026
Angela Ferreira
Miami, FL, USA
★★★★☆

I bought a pair of diamond stud earrings from Rare Carat and I'm really happy with the purchase. The stones are bright and match well which I was worried about since I ordered them online. The process was straightforward and I appreciated that they showed me independent lab reports for each stone. Delivery took about a week which was reasonable. I'd definitely shop here again for future jewelry purchases. Just wish there were more setting style options to choose from.

Jewelry Store Feb 19, 2025
Diana Kowalski
Chicago, IL, USA
★★★★☆

Rare Carat helped me upgrade my existing engagement ring without breaking the bank. I traded up to a larger stone and the whole process was handled professionally. The gemologist consultation was genuinely helpful and not just a sales pitch. I appreciated that they were upfront about which stones were better value and which ones I should skip. The new ring is gorgeous and I get stopped constantly with people asking about it. Would shop here again without hesitation.

Wholesale Jeweler Aug 30, 2024
Darnell Prescott
Atlanta, GA, USA
★★★★☆

Buying an engagement ring as a surprise is stressful but Rare Carat made it manageable. I appreciated how they break down every diamond characteristic in plain English. The Rare Score feature was especially helpful in narrowing down my choices. I settled on a beautiful 1.1 carat pear shaped diamond and had it set in a custom halo ring. My fiancée was blown away. The only small complaint is the return process documentation was a bit confusing but thankfully I didn't need to use it.

Jewelry Designer Oct 9, 2023
Lindsey Chambers
Minneapolis, MN, USA
★★★★☆

Really solid experience shopping at Rare Carat for my mother's birthday gift. I picked out a beautiful diamond pendant with a pear shaped stone and the quality exceeded my expectations for the price. The site made it easy to filter by budget and the product photos were accurate to what arrived. Shipping was well packaged and the piece came with a nice gift box. I knocked off one star only because I had to follow up twice to get a shipping confirmation email, but the product itself is wonderful.

Jewelry Store Feb 18, 2023