Community listing

J.C. Taylor Insurance

21 reviews .
★★★☆☆
2.6
Vehicles & Transportation
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Vehicles & Transportation https://jctaylor.com/

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Thomas Greenberg
Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA
★☆☆☆☆

This company is a complete disaster when it comes to communication. I called four times over two weeks trying to update my policy after completing a restoration on my 1965 GTO, and not once did anyone call me back. I finally got someone on the phone who promised to send updated documents and I'm still waiting. If this is how they treat existing customers, I can only imagine what filing a claim would be like. Looking for a new insurer immediately.

Auto Insurance Agency Jan 17, 2025
Kevin Ashworth
Des Moines, Iowa, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Signed up for a policy on my 1966 Ford Galaxie and within two months they sent a cancellation notice with almost no explanation. When I called to find out why, I was transferred three times and given vague answers about underwriting guidelines. No one could tell me specifically what the issue was. I had to scramble to find new coverage and lost time and money in the process. Totally unprofessional handling of the situation.

Auto Insurance Agency Aug 12, 2024
Raymond Kowalski
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Filed a claim when hail damaged the hood and roof of my 1969 Chevelle and the experience was infuriating from start to finish. The adjuster they sent clearly had no experience with classic cars and used generic repair estimates that didn't account for the specialty work required. It took five months to settle and I ended up getting less than half of what the repairs actually cost me. I had to pay out of pocket to make my car right. This is not the coverage they advertise.

Auto Insurance Agency Mar 10, 2024
Frank Delacroix
New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
★☆☆☆☆

My 1964 Impala was stolen from my driveway and the claims process with J.C. Taylor has been absolutely horrific. It has been four months and I still have not received a settlement. Every time I call I get a different representative who doesn't seem to know the status of my claim. I've been asked to submit the same documents multiple times. I hired an attorney to help me navigate this and she said she's seen this pattern of delay tactics before. Do not trust this company with your prized vehicle.

Auto Insurance Agency Oct 22, 2023
Janet Pullman
Louisville, Kentucky, USA
★☆☆☆☆

I was trying to use J.C. Taylor's auto broker service to locate a specific classic car and the experience was terrible. The representative I worked with seemed disinterested and barely followed up after our initial conversation. I had to chase them down for updates and when they did respond the options they presented had nothing to do with what I described. Wasted two months with this service and ended up finding the car on my own through other channels. Very unprofessional.

Auto Broker Mar 5, 2023
Mitchell Graves
Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Paid my premium for over two years without a single claim and when a garage fire damaged my 1968 Shelby GT500 they treated me like a suspect instead of a customer. They sent an investigator, delayed the process for months, and the settlement offer they finally made was insulting given the documented value of the car. I had to threaten legal action before they came anywhere close to a fair number. No collector car owner should have to go through what I experienced.

Auto Insurance Agency Jul 5, 2022