I submitted a claim after my 1958 Corvette was damaged during transport to a car show and the process has been an absolute nightmare. It took over three weeks just to get an adjuster assigned, and when they finally reviewed the damage, the estimate they came back with was laughably low. I provided three independent appraisals showing the repair cost and they still pushed back. I feel like they collect premiums happily but fight every claim tooth and nail.
Business Overview
Core company details visible to potential customers.
Customer Reviews
Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.
I specifically asked before signing up whether my car was covered while parked at my restoration shop and was told yes. After a break-in caused significant damage to the interior of my 1971 Dodge Charger, they denied the claim citing exclusions I was never made aware of. I feel misled. The coverage that was described to me over the phone and what was actually in the fine print of the policy were two very different things. Very disappointed.
I was excited to insure my 1953 Hudson Hornet with a company that specializes in classics, but the experience has been underwhelming. The agreed value I submitted was questioned and they came back asking for additional documentation repeatedly over a period of months. By the time everything was finalized I had wasted enormous amounts of time. The policy is in place now but I'm already researching competitors because this process should not have been this complicated.
The premiums went up significantly at my renewal with no real explanation beyond a generic letter about market conditions. When I asked for a breakdown of why my rate increased by nearly 30 percent, no one could give me a satisfactory answer. I've made no claims in four years with this company. Loyal customers deserve better treatment than this. I'm shopping around and will likely be moving my policy before the renewal date.
Used the auto broker service hoping for a smooth experience buying a collector car and ended up frustrated throughout. Communication was inconsistent, timelines were never met, and at one point I wasn't sure if anyone was actually working on finding the car I requested. The one option they did present had undisclosed rust issues that I discovered during my own inspection. I expected a specialist broker to do better due diligence than this.
Had a policy with J.C. Taylor for my 1960 Pontiac Bonneville and ran into serious issues when I tried to transfer the policy after gifting the car to my son. The process was confusing, the paperwork requirements were never clearly explained, and there was a gap in coverage during the transfer that nobody warned us about. Luckily nothing happened during that time but the lack of transparency about the process was really concerning for a company that specializes in valuable collector cars.