J.C. Taylor Insurance

I've been insuring my 1967 Mustang with J.C. Taylor for three years now and the experience has been outstanding. Their agreed value policy gave me peace of mind knowing my classic car is covered for what it's actually worth, not some depreciated book value. When I had a minor fender bender at a car show last summer, the claims process was smooth and the payout was fair. Highly recommend them to any classic car enthusiast.

J.C. Taylor came through for me when other insurance companies wouldn't even touch my 1955 Bel Air. The agent I spoke with actually knew what he was talking about when it came to collector cars, which made the whole process feel trustworthy. My premium is reasonable and the coverage is exactly what I was looking for. This is a company that genuinely understands the classic car community.

Solid insurance option for classic car owners. I insure my 1972 Chevelle through them and have been happy with the policy terms. The agreed value coverage is the main reason I chose them over competitors. The only reason I'm giving four stars instead of five is that the online portal could use some modernization, but the actual coverage and customer service over the phone has been great.

After shopping around for classic car insurance for months, J.C. Taylor offered the best combination of price and coverage for my 1969 Camaro. Their mileage-based policy works perfectly for a car that I only drive to shows and on weekends. The staff is knowledgeable and patient, answering all my questions without making me feel rushed. Very satisfied with this company.

J.C. Taylor has been insuring my 1963 Thunderbird for two years. The policy is straightforward and the price is very competitive compared to what I was paying before. When I called with a question about updating my agreed value after a restoration, the agent handled it quickly and professionally. Good company for collector car owners who want real coverage.

Switched to J.C. Taylor after a bad experience with a mainstream insurer who tried to pay out actual cash value on my 1970 Plymouth Barracuda. J.C. Taylor's agreed value policy is exactly what classic car owners need. The entire sign-up process was easy, the rate was lower than I expected, and the agent actually seemed excited about my car. That personal touch matters a lot to collectors like me.

I submitted a claim after my 1958 Corvette was damaged during transport to a car show and the process has been an absolute nightmare. It took over three weeks just to get an adjuster assigned, and when they finally reviewed the damage, the estimate they came back with was laughably low. I provided three independent appraisals showing the repair cost and they still pushed back. I feel like they collect premiums happily but fight every claim tooth and nail.

This company is a complete disaster when it comes to communication. I called four times over two weeks trying to update my policy after completing a restoration on my 1965 GTO, and not once did anyone call me back. I finally got someone on the phone who promised to send updated documents and I'm still waiting. If this is how they treat existing customers, I can only imagine what filing a claim would be like. Looking for a new insurer immediately.