Community listing

Rare Carat

21 reviews .
★★★★☆
3.8
Shopping & Fashion
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Shopping & Fashion https://www.rarecarat.com/

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Samuel Torres
Phoenix, AZ, USA
★★★★★

Rare Carat is the Amazon of diamond buying and I mean that in the best way. The sheer volume of certified stones available at competitive prices is remarkable. I did a side by side comparison of dozens of round diamonds and selected one with an excellent cut grade and D color that would have cost me nearly double at a traditional jeweler. The checkout process was secure, shipping was insured, and the stone arrived in perfect condition. Game changer for anyone in the market for diamonds.

Diamond Dealer May 5, 2024
Melissa Huang
Seattle, WA, USA
★★★★★

I've purchased from Rare Carat twice now and both experiences were excellent. The first time was for an engagement ring and the second time for a diamond pendant as an anniversary gift. Consistent quality, honest pricing, and great customer support both times. I love that every diamond comes with a lab certificate so I know exactly what I'm getting. My husband was equally impressed when I showed him how much we saved compared to the quotes we got from local stores.

Jewelry Store Dec 14, 2023
Darnell Prescott
Atlanta, GA, USA
★★★★☆

Buying an engagement ring as a surprise is stressful but Rare Carat made it manageable. I appreciated how they break down every diamond characteristic in plain English. The Rare Score feature was especially helpful in narrowing down my choices. I settled on a beautiful 1.1 carat pear shaped diamond and had it set in a custom halo ring. My fiancée was blown away. The only small complaint is the return process documentation was a bit confusing but thankfully I didn't need to use it.

Jewelry Designer Oct 9, 2023
Rachel Nguyen
Portland, OR, USA
★★★★★

I was skeptical about buying a diamond online but Rare Carat completely won me over. Every stone listed has an independent lab certificate and their gemologist review service gave me peace of mind before committing. I bought a beautiful 0.9 carat round diamond for a solitaire setting and it is absolutely stunning. The price was fair and the shipping was fast and insured. I will never go back to buying diamonds in person after this experience. Rare Carat has a customer for life.

Diamond Dealer Jul 7, 2023
Thomas Baxter
Boston, MA, USA
★★★★★

Rare Carat is a must for anyone buying diamonds. I spent months preparing to propose and the research phase was overwhelming until I discovered their platform. I used their free gemologist check on three different diamonds before choosing the perfect one. The 1.4 carat oval I selected had incredible brilliance and the price was unbeatable. The ring arrived in a beautiful presentation box and my girlfriend was in tears when I proposed. Couldn't be happier with the entire experience.

Diamond Dealer May 12, 2023
Lindsey Chambers
Minneapolis, MN, USA
★★★★☆

Really solid experience shopping at Rare Carat for my mother's birthday gift. I picked out a beautiful diamond pendant with a pear shaped stone and the quality exceeded my expectations for the price. The site made it easy to filter by budget and the product photos were accurate to what arrived. Shipping was well packaged and the piece came with a nice gift box. I knocked off one star only because I had to follow up twice to get a shipping confirmation email, but the product itself is wonderful.

Jewelry Store Feb 18, 2023
Gary Hutchinson
Dallas, TX, USA
★★☆☆☆

I had a frustrating experience with Rare Carat that I feel I need to share. The diamond I received looked noticeably different from the online photos. The color appeared at least two grades warmer than advertised and when I reached out to customer service it took over a week to get a response. When I asked about returning the stone the process was complicated and required me to ship it back at my own expense before any refund would be considered. For a premium purchase I expected much better service.

Diamond Dealer Aug 13, 2022
Sandra Perkins
Sacramento, CA, USA
★☆☆☆☆

Terrible experience from start to finish. I ordered a custom engagement ring and was given a six week timeline. It arrived ten weeks later with no proactive communication from their team. I had to reschedule my proposal twice. When the ring finally showed up, one of the prongs on the setting was visibly uneven. I contacted customer service and was told I could send it back for repair but that would take another four to six weeks. I'm absolutely devastated by how this turned out.

Jewelry Designer Jul 30, 2022