I expected more from a company with so many glowing reviews. The diamond I purchased was listed as VS2 clarity but when I had it independently appraised locally the appraiser pointed out inclusions that he would have graded SI1. When I brought this up with Rare Carat they kept pointing me to the GIA certificate and were not willing to engage with my concerns meaningfully. The customer service rep I spoke with was dismissive. I won't be shopping here again.
Business Overview
Core company details visible to potential customers.
Customer Reviews
Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.
Mixed feelings about Rare Carat. The diamond selection and pricing are genuinely great and I found a stone I loved. The problem was the setting I ordered arrived with a small scratch on the band that looked like a manufacturing defect. Customer service was polite but the resolution process was slow. They offered a partial credit which I accepted, but the whole back and forth took nearly three weeks. The diamond itself is beautiful though so I'm giving three stars instead of one.
I would give zero stars if I could. I ordered a diamond for an engagement ring and paid for expedited shipping to ensure it arrived before my trip. The diamond arrived four days late, completely missing the window I needed. When I explained the situation and asked for a refund on the shipping cost I was told that expedited shipping fees are non-refundable. No apology, no accommodation. The diamond itself seems fine but the customer service experience was one of the worst I've had with any retailer.
I wanted to love Rare Carat because the concept is great, but my experience was disappointing. I ordered a wholesale lot of smaller diamonds for a jewelry project and several stones arrived with chips that were not disclosed in the listing. Getting through to someone who could actually help was a challenge. After multiple emails and a phone call I was offered a store credit rather than a refund. I needed the money back, not a credit, and the unwillingness to accommodate that felt really unreasonable.
Rare Carat has a great platform and I genuinely enjoyed the browsing experience. The AI recommendations and Rare Score system are legitimately useful tools. However, after I placed my order I ran into issues. The diamond took nearly three weeks to arrive with no tracking updates for the first ten days. When I contacted support I got canned responses that didn't address my specific questions. The diamond was fine when it finally showed up, but the post-purchase experience left a lot to be desired for something this expensive.